Benchmarks: How Every Reading Is Checked
Updated
On a survey, a benchmark is a fixed mark of known height that other readings are tied to. Every figure and number on Meridian & Moraine is tied to something of that kind: a published source, a data set with a named version, or a calculation whose inputs are printed beside the article. This page sets out those ties, one kind of figure at a time, and says what a page will not claim.
Satellite images
Satellite images come from two open sources: Copernicus Sentinel-2 Level-2A data, and data from the ABI imager on NOAA's GOES-18 and GOES-19 satellites, distributed through NOAA's open data program.
Changes to an image are limited to cropping, resampling and one color stretch shared by the red, green and blue bands. There is no sharpening, no band-by-band color adjustment, no cloud removal and no retouching, and the stretch values are recorded with the image. An image is never enlarged beyond its original resolution, so a narrow scene stays narrow.
Before an image is used, it passes a fixed set of checks:
- Pairs. Two scenes shown side by side share one stretch and the same major processing version. Scenes from different processing generations are never paired, because the difference would look like change on the ground.
- Scale and north. The scale bar is computed from the image's georeferencing, then checked by computing the geodesic distance between its two ends. The north arrow follows true north at the center of the frame.
- Locations. Coordinates from a published source are converted to the image's own reference frame before use, including those given in an older survey frame such as NAD27, and each point must land within one pixel of its place. When a source table lists the same point twice, in grid coordinates and in latitude and longitude, the two must agree; when they do not, the page says which it follows and why.
- Dates and coverage. Cloud over the frame, blank pixels and the capture date are checked. An image tied to a dated event must come from inside that event's dated window, as given by a weather service record or another readable source.
- Labels. Labels, scale bars and north arrows are drawn on a separate layer above the image and never burned into it.
Every satellite figure's credit line names the scene or file and the year or time of capture. Images built from GOES data also state that they are not original, unaltered NOAA data.
A size that comes from a published source rather than from the image, such as the width of a ring-shaped structure, is labeled as the source's figure and is not presented as a measurement on the image.
Only features wide enough to read are read. In Sentinel-2's 10-meter pixels that means landforms about ten pixels across or more, roughly 100 meters and up; GOES pixels span about 0.5 to 2 kilometers, so GOES images are used only for air patterns many kilometers wide. The site does not offer images of places on request.
A landform is named in an image only when a published source supports the same place, the same landform and the same claim. Matching coordinates are not enough on their own; a statement about how or when the landform formed needs its own source. Anything without that support is described only by its shape, color and position and is labeled visible in imagery. That distance between seeing and knowing is the ground-truth gap, and a label never closes it.
Contour and relief maps
Contours and shaded relief are computed from public elevation models: USGS 3DEP data, through The National Map, for the United States, and swisstopo elevation data for Switzerland. Each figure names its elevation model and version in the line beneath it. The contour interval is printed on the map itself. At least five points per map are checked by comparing the model's elevation with the contour value drawn there, and the results go into the article's data file.
Shaded relief always states its light: the direction the light comes from, as an azimuth, and its height above the horizon, on the figure and in the data file. Drawn maps are also checked for position: the corner coordinates of each map are recomputed from the elevation model's own georeferencing.
An article carries no more than three new maps, and each map page names the cartographer's cut of its own map, such as the small rises hidden by the interval or the direction chosen for the light. Where a source shows a disputed area, it is drawn as the source draws it and labeled disputed.
Old maps, prints and photographs
Each old map, geologic map, print or photograph is cleared on its own. Its license, or the basis on which it is in the public domain, is read from the record for that single image and is never inferred from the reputation of the collection that holds it. A public-domain image has a stated reason: a U.S. federal government work, the creator's year of death under the law that applies, or the source's own CC0 or public-domain mark. Anonymous prints and photographs are judged by their date of publication. Licenses that forbid commercial use or derivative works rule an image out.
An error on an old map is described from what the map itself shows. A cause for the error is given only where a readable source states one.
A modern outline set beside an old map, such as a coastline, is drawn from public data with its version named, and is shown next to the old map rather than laid over it, so no claim is made that the two line up point for point.
Rock sections and columns
Cross-sections and columns of rock layers are drawn from the thicknesses, tilts and ages given in published sources, never traced from someone else's figure. Wherever a drawing simplifies, its caption says "schematic, not to scale".
Ages come from the chart of the International Commission on Stratigraphy, cited with its version, and from individual papers. When sources disagree, both readings are shown side by side. At Siccar Point, for example, John Playfair in 1805 described the upper beds as horizontal, while the British Geological Survey's Earthwise describes them dipping seaward at about 15 degrees, and the page gives both.
Angles in the sky
Rainbow angles are recomputed with a model of light refracted into a water drop and reflected once or twice inside it, using a stated wavelength and refractive index. Where a refractive index is an assumed value rather than one taken from a source, the page and its data file say so. Angles are given relative to the antisolar point, the spot directly opposite the Sun, never as a distance from the Sun. If a recomputed angle differs from the published value by more than half a degree, the figure is not published.
Glories and coronas get no computed angles; a page describes them only as far as its sources do. Hand-span angles follow the U.S. National Park Service's rough guide, with a little finger at about 1 degree, a thumb at about 2, a fist at about 10 and a spread hand at about 20, and they are labeled rough because hands and arms differ.
Cloud names
Cloud genera, levels and definitions follow the U.S. National Weather Service's Observing Handbook No. 1 (2010) and the American Meteorological Society's Glossary of Meteorology. The glossary is paraphrased and quoted only briefly. Luke Howard's 1803 paper is quoted from page images of the original. The World Meteorological Organization's International Cloud Atlas appears in bibliographies only.
A cloud photograph is labeled to genus, never to species or variety, and only when the image record names the genus and the picture shows that genus's features. If the two disagree, the photograph is not used.
Sources and how they rank
When sources conflict, national weather, geological and mapping agencies and the International Commission on Stratigraphy come first. Peer-reviewed papers come next, then society glossaries, then public-domain originals (cited with their year), then textbooks. A conflict between sources of the same rank is shown on the page, not settled quietly.
Every age, coordinate, angle, distance and area needs a source, and so does every claim of a largest, oldest or first, every fact about a historical map or its maker, and every piece of folklore. Each entry in a page's Sources list states its depth of reading, whether complete or limited to an abstract or summary. A work available only as a catalog entry cannot carry a headline, a short answer or a summary line. Open encyclopedias and wikis may lead to a source but are never cited as one. Copyrighted text is paraphrased, with short quotations at most.
Data files
Where a figure rests on numbers, a downloadable CSV file holds them. Each row holds a single claim and cites it, so a row read alone still stands. A qualifier column carries each limit, such as "approximate", "one study" or "different water levels; not a trend", so the limit stays with the value. Values computed by the site record the version of the calculation that produced them.